Brand Teardown: How Magic Spoon Turns Six $9.75 Boxes Into a Subscription

Magic Spoon keeps the price hidden until your box is full. We walked every stage of its build-your-own-box funnel and screenshotted all of them.

Anna P.4 min read
On this page6 sections
  1. 01Stage 1. You pick the size before you pick anything else
  2. 02Stage 2. You fill it yourself
  3. 03Stage 3. The price arrives last
  4. 04Stage 4. The cart adds something you didn't pick
  5. 05Stage 5. Cross $55 and a second gift lands
  6. 06Three things to steal

Magic Spoon sells cereal at $9.75 a box. The shop won't sell you one on its own. Everything there comes in fours, sixes and eights.

What you can do is build your own box of six. Getting that box to a checkout button takes five stages, and we took a screenshot at every one.

Here's what each stage does.

Stage 1. You pick the size before you pick anything else

The first screen asks one question: 4, 6 or 8 boxes.

Every option carries its own discount. Four boxes save up to 20%. Six save up to 24%, arrive pre-selected, and wear a MOST POPULAR tag. Eight save up to 26% and get BEST VALUE.

No prices appear yet. You get percentages, a star rating with 31,111 reviews behind it, and a decision about volume you're making before you've seen a single flavor.

Magic Spoon step one: a 4, 6 or 8 Pack choice with Save Up To 20, 24 and 26 percent, the 6 Pack tagged MOST POPULAR, above a grid of Cocoa and Fruity cereal boxes at $9.75 each

Stage 2. You fill it yourself

Next come the flavors: 31 of them across cereal, oatmeal, treats, granola and pastries. Everything costs $9.75 except oatmeal, which costs $7.99 for five packets.

There's a shortcut if you'd rather not choose. ALL STAR, DISCOVERY KIT and TREATS VARIETY fill the box for you in one tap.

If you do choose, tap ADD and three things change at once. The card turns cyan. The button becomes a quantity stepper. A bar across the bottom starts counting: 2/6 PRODUCTS SELECTED... ADD MORE.

Something smaller happens inside the cards. The Fruity box photo swaps for a bowl of the cereal, poured and ready. You stop looking at packaging.

That counter bar follows you down the page until the number reaches six.

Two Magic Spoon cereal cards turned cyan with quantity steppers after being added, and a bar across the bottom reading 2 of 6 products selected, add more

Stage 3. The price arrives last

Hit 6/6 and two things will land at the same time.

A price appears at the top of the page: $58.50 struck through, $44.40 next to it.

The bottom bar opens into a plan choice. ONE-TIME PURCHASE costs $55.50. SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 24% costs $44.40, comes pre-selected, and carries a delivery frequency with it. The default reads "Delivered every 30 days", and the dropdown also offers 14, 45 and 60. The button reads $44.40 | ADD TO CART.

You've built the thing first. You find out what it costs second. And the cheaper of the two numbers has a subscription attached to it.

The Magic Spoon builder at 6 of 6 products selected, with a plan choice of one-time purchase $55.50 or Subscribe and Save 24% at $44.40 pre-selected, and a $44.40 add to cart button

Stage 4. The cart adds something you didn't pick

One tap opens the cart with two items in it.

The first line holds your six boxes at $44.40, listed flavor by flavor, with $58.50 struck through. The second holds a Free Bowl & Spoon Set, Subscriber Gift, $0.00, with $23.00 struck through beside it.

You didn't choose the bowl. Subscribing chose it for you.

Below that, MORE FOR YOUR BOWL offers single boxes at $9.75. That's where the one-box option lives, and you'll only reach it once there's a bundle in the cart.

The Magic Spoon cart holding a Free Bowl and Spoon Set subscriber gift at $0.00 marked down from $23.00, a six-box custom bundle at $44.40 from $58.50, a cross-sell box at $9.75, and a $44.40 subtotal above checkout

Stage 5. Cross $55 and a second gift lands

A banner has been running along the top of the site the whole time promising free protein treats on orders over $55. The subscribe price, $44.40, lands under that line. The one-time price, $55.50, clears it.

Add one $9.75 box from the cross-sell and the cart answers the question for you. A GIFT! Treats Sampler Pack appears at $0.00, down from $9.75, tagged "Congratulations! Free gift with your order."

The cheaper plan drops you under the gift line. The cross-sell underneath it is how you get back over.

The same Magic Spoon cart after a single $9.75 box is added: a GIFT Treats Sampler Pack appears at $0.00 marked down from $9.75, with savings of $60.95 and a $63.90 subtotal above checkout

Three things to steal

  • Ask for the commitment before the price. Size first, flavors second, cost third. By the time the number shows up, your shopper has already built something.
  • Make the subscription the cheaper default. $11.10 separates the two plans, the cheaper one comes pre-selected, and accepting it costs no extra clicks.
  • Put the gift in the cart instead of the copy. A $23.00 bowl listed at $0.00 reads like something you've already got. The same bowl in a banner reads like an ad.

One thing worth your time: Magic Spoon is split-testing this builder. The version in our screenshots labels the plan panel "Select your plan". A few hours later the same URL served us a different version. That one numbers the panel "3 Choose Your Frequency" and adds a Your Bundle Variety tracker, which counts how many of the five categories you've got. Check your own screen before copying ours.

Thirty-one products across a six-slot box turns into a variant problem long before it turns into a marketing one. Order bundling in Funnelish covers that half of it.

The stages themselves take an afternoon. E-commerce funnels on Funnelish let you lay them out in the same order and watch which stage loses people.

Written by

Anna P.

Writes for the Funnelish blog: playbooks on funnels, checkout, payments and growth for DTC brands.

Build funnels like this

See how brands like this run on Funnelish

Landing pages, bundles, subscribe-and-save, order bumps and one-click upsells on one platform, built for DTC brands that grow with paid ads.

Or start a free 14-day trial, no credit card required.

4,600+ merchants sold over $3.8B+ on Funnelish